Skip to content

Home Office pulls approval for some motorway speed cameras in England

3 minute read

National Highways is ending enforcement with some variable speed cameras on England's motorways after the Home Office revoked the system's type approval over faults dating to an upgrade that began in 2019.

"Ministers are not prepared to accept any scenario where there is a hypothetical risk some drivers could be prosecuted incorrectly," the Department for Transport said in a written statement to Parliament on Tuesday, Nov. 17.

In the first fault, the cameras sometimes missed rapid changes to the limits shown on variable speed signs. On very rare occasions, drivers got too little time to react to a new limit, or were caught speeding after it had already changed. Around 0.2 percent of England's roads were affected.

The government said it has offered redress to every driver it could trace and reach, and will keep doing so as it finds other eligible people.

Later testing by National Highways and the Home Office turned up a possible second problem from the same 2019 upgrade, in how the cameras may activate in particular conditions. Modelling by National Highways put the chance of those conditions at no more than 0.1 percent, with no real-world evidence that they affected enforcement.

Ruling out a fix to its satisfaction in any reasonable timeframe, the Home Office revoked the type approval, which makes camera data easier to admit as evidence in some legal proceedings. Their purchase depended on the cameras keeping that approval. They no longer have it. The agency is now ending its contract with supplier Verra Mobility to use them for enforcement and is weighing further commercial and legal options.

"Drivers will see no difference in the way they use roads," the department said. Action can still be taken against people who break the law, it added.

From Nov. 17, National Highways put extra traffic officer patrols at the affected sites and began using existing CCTV cameras to help watch compliance. Stopped vehicle detection radars and existing ANPR cameras remain in use to identify offenders, and other enforcement tactics stay in place on all motorways and A roads. Variable speed signs stay switched on, used for safety, for keeping traffic moving and for easing congestion.

Patrols and data collection show that compliance "remains at the usual high levels on these roads, which remain safe," the department said.

An independent review published on Nov. 17 examined how the first fault arose and how it was handled once found. Led by Tracy Westall OBE and commissioned by the Secretary of State for Transport, the Westall Review looks at missed chances to spot, investigate and escalate the problem, and at how National Highways worked with police and partners.

Its recommendations cover seven themes, among them data and technology, crisis handling, legal advice, corporate governance, and procurement and contracting. They aim to lower the risk of a repeat and improve how National Highways responds when something goes wrong. After the second fault surfaced, Westall went back over them and found they still held, unchanged.

Both the government and National Highways have accepted the recommendations, and the agency has started making improvements. Through existing sponsorship arrangements, the Department for Transport will monitor its progress and hold it to account.

Published on

Author

Megapolis News

Up next

US lets Maryland power unit run through Dec. 31 to cut outage risk in 13 states